Historical Trend Analysis and Future of Federalism in Iraq

Document Type : Original Article

Authors

1 M.A. in International Relations, Ferdowsi University of Mashhad, Iran

2 Professor of Political Science, Ferdowsi University of Mashhad, Iran

3 Assistant Professor of Geography, Ferdowsi University of Mashhad, Iran

Abstract

Introduction
From the beginning of its formation as an independent geographical unit under the monarchy to the current federalism system of government the political process in contemporary Iraq has been influenced by external and internal factors, and instability has always overshadowed this country and what is now apparent in modern Iraq is that still the new political system remains unstable. Iraq, recognized as one of the legacy states of the collapse of the Ottoman Empire and the outcome of the post-World War I conquest, since its inception, violence and logistical strife has continued with the fall of the Ba'athist regime and the establishment of a federal system. In fact, federalism in Iraq is the heir to a tumultuous history, fragmented society, ethnic-sectarian sociological divisions, concentration of power by a minority of communities, the status of Kirkuk and other contested areas, forcible Arabization and emigration from the former systems and many problems are remained unresolved. With such a situation and background, it is difficult to imagine Iraq free of violence and conflict. In fact, what has happened since the fall of Saddam in Iraq has been the failure of the new political system to repair the existing sociological gaps in Iraqi society, to provide security and public services, and to solve some of the former problems. Regarding that countries are in a form of interaction, the unstable situation in Iraq can also affect the other countries of the region, so in order to explain the subject under study, it seems necessary to conduct this research.
Methodology
This research investigates the future of Iraq's federalism system for the horizon of 2030, based on historical trend analysis that relying on the factors which influence the situation in this country. At first, the areas of influence in the field of Iraqi federalism and its presentation to the elites were determined by the list of variables of each constituency, followed by a review of the opinions of the elite group and then are verified. Also, based on the influential factors in the situation of the country, the data were collected using Delphi method and finally, by entering the variables into the Micmac software, relevant analysis was presented and the target, independent, risk variables, etc. were identified and key proponents were identified. They were classified according to the situation in Iraq. Then, by adapting propellants, details of effective parameters in probable scenarios were formulated, and challenge and potential analysis of each domain was performed. And while analyzing the hypotheses, the proposals of each domain were also expressed.
 
Result and Discussion
Accordingly, three scenarios are presented: desirable scenario (considering Iraq in true federalism with non-centralization and balanced distribution of wealth and power), optimistic scenario (reminiscent of its current state and continuing the current political system shaky and unstable) and crisis scenario (on the one hand, they represent the collapse of Iraq and, in other words, the rise of the demands for independence and the return of the authoritarian political system).
 
Conclusions
Because the nature of the government in Iraq has been at odds with the multicultural nature of its society since the beginning of its political life, and because of its centenary history, and issues such as the insurgency, the coup, the revolution, the civil war, and there has always been a shadow of strife and strife, producing a fragile structure, Iraq has been a bankrupt country since the fall of the Ba'athist regime, with few signs of improving the political process. Based on the variables and discussions around the subject given the circumstances in Iraq, and in answer to the research questions it can be said that two scenarios of optimism and crisis in the horizon set for Iraqi federalism are likely.

Keywords


  1. Abdi, Atallah and Shirzad, Sakar. (2016). “The Role of Geographic Spaces in the Competition of Superpowers; A Case Study of Iraq”, Geopolitics Quarterly, 12 (3), Pp. 54-84. [In Persian]
  2. Ahmadi, Curosh. (2005). "The Iraqi Constitutional Process: Analyzes and Perspectives," in [Iraq after the fall of Baghdad], Tehran: Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Press and Publications Center, 23-23. [In Persian]
  3. Ahmadi, Farajollah and Qazvin Haieri, Yasser. (2010). "The Iraqi Constitution Drafting Process". Journal of Politics, 40 (2), 19-19. [In Persian]
  4. Ahmadipour, Zahra & Mubarakshahi, Mahmoud (2015). “Barriers to Kirkuk's Accession to the Kurdistan Regional Government (Iraq)”. Geopolitics Quarterly, 11(2), Pp. 35-59. [In Persian]
  5. Auer, A. (2005). “The constitutional scheme of federalism”. Journal of European Public Policy, 12(3), 419-431. DOI: 10.1080/13501760500091166.
  6. Bremer, Paul. (2006). Memories of the first American ruler after Saddam. Translation: Mir Hassan Raizadeh. (2006). Tehran: Blue. [In Persian]
  7. Brown, N. J. (2005). Iraq's Constitutional Process Plunges Ahead (p. 7). Carnegie Endowment for International Peace.
  8. Brown, N. J. (2005). Iraq's Constitutional Process Plunges Ahead (p. 7). Carnegie Endowment for International Peace.
  9. Burgess, M., & Gagnon, A. (1993). Comparative federalism and federation: Competing traditions and future directions. Univ of Toronto Pr.
  10. Congleton, R. D., Kyriacou, A., & Bacaria, J. (2003). “A theory of menu federalism: Decentralization by political agreement”. Constitutional Political Economy, 14(3), 167-190.
  11. Cordell, Carl and Wolf, Stephen. (2009). Ethnic Conflicts. Translation: Abdullah Ramazanzadeh. Tehran: Culturology in collaboration with the Mizan. [In Persian]
  12. Dawisha, A. (2005). “The prospects for democracy in Iraq: Challenges and opportunities”. Third World Quarterly, 26(4-5), 723-737. DOI: 10.1080/01436590500128329.
  13. Dawisha, A. (2009). Iraq: a political history from independence to occupation. Princeton University Press.
  14. Dikshit, R. D. (1971). “Geography and federalism”. Annals of the Association of American Geographers, 61(1), 97-115.
  15. Dodge, T. (2005). “Iraqi Transitions: from regime change to state collapse”. Third World Quarterly, 26(4-5), 705-721. DOI: 10.1080/01436590500127982.
  16. Eslami, Masoud & Shams Abadi, Ali. (2018). “Causes of Iraqi Kurdistan's referendum failure”. Geopolitics Quarterly, 14 (3), Pp. 63-94. [In Persian]
  17. Feldman, N., & Martinez, R. (2006). “Constitutional politics and text in the new Iraq: An experiment in Islamic democracy”. FordhaM L. rev., 75, 883.
  18. Gharayagh zand, Davud. (2010). "The Nation-Building Process of Statehood, National Identity Formation and Reconstruction in Iraq: Historical Experiences and the Outlook." Strategic Studies. (47). [In Persian]
  19. Ghazi, Abolfazl. (1996). Speeches in Public Law. Tehran: Dadgostar. [In Persian]
  20. Ginsburg, T., & Dixon, R. (Eds.). (2011). Comparative constitutional law. Edward Elgar Publishing.
  21. Hanish, S. (2015). “FEDERALISM IN IRAQ: ASSESSMENT. PEOPLE”. International Journal of Social Sciences, 1(1).
  22. Hassanzadeh, Aso. (2005). Federalism for Kurdish. Erbil: Mukiyani Publications.
  23. Kane, S., Hiltermann, J. R., & Alkadiri, R. (2012). “Iraq's Federalism Quandary”. The National Interest, (118), 20-30. DOI: 10.1080/07036337.2010. 526711.
  24. Karimi, Ali. (2011). An Introduction to the Sociology of Ethnic Diversity; Issues and Theories. Tehran: Samt. [In Persian]
  25. Kaviani Rad, Morad & Boye, Chamran. (2012). “The place of the concept of vital space in shaping Iraqi foreign policy”. Geopolitics Quarterly, 8 (1), Pp. 112-134. [In Persian]
  26. Khalilzad, Zalmi. (2016). From Kabul to the White House, my journey into the turbulent world. Translation: Haron Najafizadeh. (2016). Cabol: Azem. [In Persian]
  27. Khubruye pak, Mohammad Reza. (1998). A Critique of Federalism.Tehran: Shirazeh. [In Persian]
  28. Langrick, Steven Hamzley. (1952). Iraq 1900-1950 Political, Social and Economic History. Translation: Ali Darwish. Mashhad: Astan Quds Razavi, Islamic Research Foundation. [In Persian]
  29. Maghsudi Mojtaba. (1380). Ethnic Developments in Iran; Causes and Backgrounds..Tehran: Institute of National Studies. [In Persian]
  30. Maiz, R. (1999). “Democracy, federalism and nationalism in multinational states”. Nationalism and Ethnic Politics, 5(3-4), 35-60. DOI: 10.1080/13537119 908428569.
  31. Makiya, K. (2003). “A model for post-Saddam Iraq”. Journal of Democracy, 14(3), 5-12. DOI:10.1353/jod.2003.0056.
  32. Marlin, M. (2016). “Concepts of “Decentralization” and “Federalization” in Ukraine: Political Signifiers or Distinct Constitutionalist Approaches for Devolutionary Federalism?” Nationalism and Ethnic Politics, 22(3), 278-299. DOI: 10.1080/13537113.2016.1203695.
  33. Rastgoo, Mohammad Zaman & Asadi, Ali Akbar (2017). “Geographical Restriction and Interests as a Bulwark against Disintegration of Iraq”. Geopolitics Quarterly, 13(4), PP 245-279. [In Persian]
  34. Rush, Michael. {1992}. Society and Politics: An Introduction to Political Sociology. Translation: Manouchehr Sabouri. Tehran: Samt. [In Persian]
  35. Salinger, P., & Laurent, E. (1991). Secret dossier: The hidden agenda behind the Gulf War. Penguin Group USA.
  36. Sardarnia, Khalilullah. (2011). An Introduction to Political Sociology. Tehran: The rate. [In Persian]
  37. Shakir, F. (2017). The Iraqi Federation: Origin, Operation and Significance. Routledge.
  38. Bakhtiari; Mohammad Fooladi. Qom: Imam Khomeini Educational and Research Institute. [In Persian]
  39. Vizheh, Mohammad Reza. (2014). Basic Rights. Tehran: Samt. [In Persian]
  40. Yeylaghi, Rahman. (2011). The US military invasion of Iraq and its impact on its ethnic and religious divisions. Tehran: Fekr Azin. [In Persian]
Volume 17, Issue 61
April 2021
Pages 84-115
  • Receive Date: 24 August 2019
  • Revise Date: 16 January 2020
  • Accept Date: 29 February 2020
  • First Publish Date: 21 March 2021