Geopolitics Quarterly

Geopolitics Quarterly

Analysis of the Geopolitical Isolation of the Islamic Republic of Iran

Document Type : Original Article

Authors
1 PhD student in Political Geography, Tarbiat Modares University, Tehran, Iran
2 Professor of Political Geography, Tarbiat Modares University, Tehran, Iran.
3 Assistant Professor of Political Geography, Tarbiat Modares University, Tehran, Iran.
Abstract
Extended Abstract
Introduction
Geopolitical isolation stands in stark contrast to internationalism, globalism, regionalism, interaction, and development, often reflecting a lack of understanding or alignment with national interests by external actors. It represents a complex and multifaceted challenge, combining self-imposed and externally imposed factors, which can pose significant risks to a nation’s stability and survival. In the early years following the Islamic Revolution, Iran adopted strategies such as isolationism, and later neutrality and non-alignment, particularly until the dissolution of the Soviet Union. These approaches were integral to the foreign policy of the ruling political system, aimed at mitigating vulnerabilities and safeguarding the revolution. Over time, as the Islamic Revolution stabilized, the Iran-Iraq War concluded, and the Soviet Union collapsed, a combination of Iran’s behavioral actions and the responses of rival and adversarial states contributed to a geopolitical environment that has increasingly isolated Iran in the contemporary global landscape. 
 
Methodology
This study is applied in its purpose and employs a descriptive-analytical approach in terms of nature and methodology. Data collection was conducted through library and documentary research, supplemented by field methods. The library and documentary research drew on authoritative books, articles, historical records, case studies, and domestic and international statistical databases, as well as searches across various digital repositories. For the field component, data collection was guided by library findings and utilized the Delphi method. A total of 144 university professors were selected to participate, with questionnaires distributed among them. Of these, 67 responses were fully completed and utilized for analysis.
 
 
 
 
Discussion

Historical Periods of Isolation in the Islamic Republic of Iran

 

The first period, characterized by conceptual and self-imposed isolation, spanned from the victory of the Islamic Revolution on February 11, 1979, to the end of the Iran-Iraq War on June 10, 1987. This era was marked by efforts to consolidate the revolution and protect it from external threats.
The second period saw imposed relative isolation, during which Hashemi Rafsanjani’s attempts to de-escalate tensions and normalize relations with the Western world, Europe, and the Arab world were thwarted by persistent hostility from the United States.
The third period, under Mohammad Khatami, was defined by attempts to escape isolation. However, the events of September 11, 2001, which placed Iran within the "axis of evil," coupled with the revelation of Iran’s nuclear program in late 2003, led to increased international pressure and further isolation.
The fourth period marked a shift toward hybrid isolation. During this time, the securitization of Iran’s nuclear program and Ahmadinejad’s confrontational policies toward international norms, the regional system, and global power structures not only intensified isolation but also damaged Iran’s international reputation.
The fifth period, characterized by unwanted hybrid isolation, unfolded despite Hassan Rouhani’s de-escalation efforts. The withdrawal of the United States from the JCPOA under the Trump administration, combined with Iran’s deepening involvement in regional crises such as those in Iraq, Yemen, and Syria, exacerbated the country’s isolation.

 

Factors Affecting the Geopolitical Isolation of the Islamic Republic of Iran


The conflict between the political ideology of the Islamic Revolution and the interests of rival powers has been a central factor shaping Iran’s geopolitical developments. The revolutionary ideals and principles have often clashed with the goals of regional and global actors, influencing Iran’s interactions within the geopolitical structure.
Iran’s policy of geopolitical territorialization, rooted in its ideological framework, has further contributed to its isolation. Elements such as its explicit opposition to the United States and the international system have positioned Iran in direct conflict with dominant global powers.
The country’s alignment with the Eastern Bloc, particularly its close cooperation with Russia and China, has reinforced its confrontational stance toward the United States, inviting additional challenges and pressures.
The United States’ imperialist policies, which reject Iran’s role as a hegemonic actor, have consistently targeted Iran over the past four decades. This sustained pressure has posed significant challenges to Iran’s national survival and the stability of its political system.
Iran’s relative weakness in national power compared to regional and global competitors has also played a role in its isolation. Statistical evidence highlights the country’s unfavorable position in this regard.
Finally, the lack of knowledge and insight among government agents regarding Iran’s geographical and geopolitical context, as well as regional and global issues, has exacerbated the country’s isolation. The failure of foreign policy decision-makers to fully grasp international relations and geopolitical dynamics has trapped Iran in a complex geopolitical predicament.

 
Conclusion
This study identified six primary factors, comprising 31 components that have contributed to the geopolitical isolation of the Islamic Republic of Iran. Among these factors, the lack of knowledge and insight among government agents about the country’s geographical and geopolitical situation holds the highest significance, with a score of 14.04. In contrast, Iran’s tendency toward the Eastern Bloc is the least significant factor, scoring 5.31. The findings underscore that the continuation of geopolitical isolation poses a serious threat to Iran’s national and territorial security, as well as its survival. 
.
Keywords

Subjects


  1. Ahmadi, E (2022). An independent national policy, a solution for the Islamic Republic of Iran's withdrawal from isolation (a Reflection on Russia's behavior toward Iran). Iranian Geopolitical Society, July 16, 2022. Available at: https://iag.ir/category/geopolitics-diplomacy.  [In Persian]
  2. Ansari Fard, M; Haji-Yousefi, A.M (2023). Challenges of Iran Deterrence Strategy in the Middle East: From Alliance to Gray Zone Politics. Geopolitics Quarterly. 19 (69): 96-130. [In Persian]
  3. Asgari, S (2021). Effective Political and Geopolitical Entropies in the Collapse the of States; Case Study: Soviet Union. Geopolitics Quarterly. 17 (61): 214-244. [In Persian]
  4. Azghandi, A (2008). Foreign policy of the Islamic Republic of Iran. Fifth edition, Tehran: Qoms Publishing. [In Persian]  
  5. Bernek, A (2015). The “Grand Chessboard” of the 21st Century Geopolitical Strategies of the Multi-Polar World. National Security Review. Special Issue/MMXV. 5-28.
  6. Boute, A (2019). Economic Statecraft and Investment Arbitration. University of Pennsylvania Journal of International Law, 40(2). Available at: SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3378551 .
  7. Cohen, S.B (1984). Geopolitics in the new world Era, chapter 2 from Reordering the world, edited by: George j. DemKo and William b. Wood. USA: Westview press.
  8. Degaard, J.P; Richar, J; Horcade, B (1999). Iran in the 20th Century: A Study of the Political, Social, Economic and Cultural Situation of Iran in the Last 100 Years. Translated by Houshang Mahdavi, A.R. Tehran: Alborz Publishing Company. [In Persian]  
  9. Dehghani Firouzabadi, S.J (2013). Foreign policy of the Islamic Republic of Iran. Tehran: Samt Publications. [In Persian]  
  10. Dehghani Firouzabadi, S.J; Moradi, M (2015). The United States and Relations of the Islamic Republic of Iran-Russian Federation. Central Asia and Caucasus Quarterly. No. 89. 66-91. [In Persian]  
  11. Ehteshami, A (1999). Transition from the crisis of succession. Tehran: Ghomes Pablications. [In Persian]
  12. Elahi, H (2017). Persian Gulf and its issues, 18th. Tehran: Ghoms Pablications. [In Persian]  
  13. Fouazi, J (2004). America and Political Islam: Confrontation of Cultures or Conflicts of Interest. Translated by Sarwaryan, M.K.  Tehran: Institute for Strategic Studies.  [In Persian]  
  14. Geldenhuys, D (1986). the Diplomacy of Isolation: South African Foreign Policy Making. The South African Institute of International Affairs.
  15. Geldenhuys, D (1991). The Politics of International Seclusion A Study of Self- Isolated States. The South African Institute of International Affairs Jan Smuts House.
  16. Geldenhuys, D (1996). Isolated States: A Comparative Analysis. 2 Edition, Cambridge University Press.
  17. Gerges, F (2013). America and Political Islam: Clash of Cultures Or Clash of Interests?. Translated by Sarwarian, M.K. Tehran: Strategic Studies Research Institute. [In Persian]
  18. Hafeznia, M.R (2006; 2017). Principlres and concept of Geopolitics. Mashhad: Papoli Pablications. [In Persian]
  19. Hafeznia, M.R. (2003). Political Geography of Iran. Tehran: Samt Publications. [In Persian]  
  20. Hafeznia, M.R (2016). The country's foreign policy is in the vortex of poverty of geopolitical insight and knowledge. Official website of Hafeznia,MR. 29 Apr. Available at: https://hafeznia.ir/2016/04. [In Persian]
  21. Hafeznia, M.R (2021). National Strategy of Space Political Management: for optimal administration and exit of Iran from the orbit of underdevelopment. The official website of Hafeznia, M. Official. November 5. Available at: https://hafeznia.ir/2021/10 . [In Persian]    
  22. Hafeznia, M.R; Boyeh, C (2015). The theory of revolution and geopolitics, explanation of Iran's geopolitics. In research-based scientific theories in political geography. Collect by Ahmadi, S & Ghorbani Nejad, R. Mashhad: Papley Publications.  [In Persian]  
  23. Hafeznia, M.R; Romina, E; Ghaderi Hajat, M (2016). Pattern of Human Structures Relationships Cultural Territories in West Asia; Emphasis on Iran's Cultural Territory. Political geography research Quarterly. 1(2). 1-29. [In Persian]   
  24. Hafeznia, M.R; Ahmadipour, Z; Boyeh, C (2012(a)). Explanation of Factors Affecting the Formation of Geopolitical Territories of Islamic Republic of Iran. Iranian Journal of International Politics Quarterly. 1(1). 49-26.  [In Persian]  
  25. Hafeznia, M.R; Ahmadipour, Z; Boyeh, C (2012(b)). The Islamic Revolution and the Emergence of New Geopolitics in Iran. Islamic Revolution Quarterly. 23(1). 1-23.  [In Persian]  
  26. Hafeznia, M.R; Kavandi Kateb, A (2017). The Raison d'etrre of Iran. Tehran: Samt Publications.  [In Persian]  
  27. Hajilo, M.H (2017). The fragility of cooperation in hegemonic atmosphere and looking east in the foreign policy of Islamic Republic of Iran. Islamic Revolution Approaches Quarterly. 11(38). 88-69. [In Persian]  
  28. Halsey, K (1997) Principles of International Policy Analysis. Translated by Mostaghimi, B & Tarom Sari, M. Tehran: Ministry of Foreign Affairs.  [In Persian]
  29. Hitchens, D.K (1997). Application of systemic thought. Translated by Aslani, R. Tehran: Institute of Public Administration. [In Persian]  
  30. Holliday, S.J (2016). Defining Iran: politics of resistance, University of Plymouth, UK.
  31. https://dictionary.cambridge.org/dictionary/english/isolation
  32. https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/isolation
  33. Karimipour, Y. (2000). Introduction to Iran and Neighbors (sources of tension and threats). Tehran: Jahad Daneshgahi Publication. [In Persian]  
  34. Katzman, K (2005). the Iran Sanctions Act. (ISA) CRS Report for Congress, 27. Available at: http://italy.usembassy. https://fas.org/sgp/crs/row/pdf.
  35. Keohane, R (1984). After hegemony: Cooperation and discord in the World political economy Princeton. Princeton University Press. N.J.
  36. Keohane, R; Nye, J.S (1977; 1987; 2001). Power & Interdependence. (1-4th Edition). Longman Classics in Political Science (1977). international Organisation (1987) & Pearson (2001).
  37. Khalili, M (2018 b). Neighboring Iran and a multi-neighbor foreign policy. Political Geography Research Quarterly. 3(1): 123-146. [In Persian]]
  38. Khalili, M (2018(A)). An Institutional Look at Iran's Foreign Policy. Tehran: The Legal Foundation of Mizan. [In Persian]  
  39. Levey, Z (2008). Israel's Exit from Africa, 1973: The Road to Diplomatic Isolation. British Journal of Middle Eastern Studies. 35(2). 205-226.
  40. Maleki, A (2004). The Islamic Revolution of Iran and the International System: Scrutiny in the Spectrum of Alignment to Confrontation. Islamic Revolution Studies Quarterly . No. 1: 91-128. [In Persian]  
  41. Maleki, A (2010). Iran’s nuclear File: recommendations for the future. Journal of Daedalus, 139 (1). 105–116.
  42. Mearsheimer, J.J (2011). Imperial by Design. The National Interest. No. 111. Center the National Interest Published.
  43. Mearsheimer, J; Walt, S.M (2016). The Case for Offshore Balancing. Foreign Affairs. 95(4).
  44. Mokhtari Hashi, H (2015). The Impact of Sanctions on the Elements of National Power, with emphasis on the United Nations Security Council Sanctions against the Islamic Republic of Iran. Geopolitics Quarterly. 11 (38): 134-173. [In Persian]
  45. Moshirzadeh, H (2017). Pathology of foreign policy: theoretical foundations. Public Policy Quarterly . 3(1).9-27. [In Persian]  
  46. Moshirzadeh, H; Jafari, H (2012). Hegemonic Power and the Revolutionary State: A Case Study of America and the Islamic Republic of Iran. Foreign Relations Quarterly. 4(1). 47-78. [In Persian]   
  47. A (2024). Challenges of Security Policy in the Era of Geopolitical Crises. Geopolitics Quarterly. 20 (73): 1-25. [In Persian]
  48. Panagiotou, R (2011). Albania and the EU: from isolation to integration. Journal of Balkan and Near Eastern Studies. 13(3). 357- 375.
  49. Porahmadi, H; Bazobandi , A (2018). Iran’s Nuclear Deal Analysis in The Framework of Putnam’s Two Level Game Theory. World Politics Quarterly. 17(3). 79-120. [In Persian]  
  50. Rahimi, A (2018). Unfamiliarity of state actors and national security challenges: the roots and remedies. National Security Watch Mahnegar, No. 80.59-64. [In Persian]  
  51. Ramezani, R (2001). An Analytical Framework for Examining the Foreign Policy of the Islamic Republic of Iran. Tehran: Ney Publishing. [In Persian]
  52. Rezaei, D; Hafeznia, M.R; Afshardi, M.H; Ahmadi Nohdani, S (2023). Explaining the Action Pattern of Geopolitical Territorialization of Countries. Geopolitics Quarterly.19 (71):1-33. [In Persian]
  53. Saree-ul-Qalam, M (2002). Foreign Policy of the Islamic Republic of Iran: Theoretical Criticism and Coalition Proposal. Parliament and Strategy Quarterly. 9(65). 65-82. [In Persian]  
  54. Saree-ul-Qalam, M (2005). Globalization of national sovereignty and Islamic Republic of Iran. Strategy Quarterly. No. 36. 246-231. [In Persian]  
  55. Saree-ul-Qalam, M (2009). Foreign Policy of the Islamic Republic of Iran: The Potential and Possibility of Change. Foreign Relations Quarterly.1 (1). 21-40. [In Persian]  
  56. Saree-ul-Qalam, M (2011). The Concept of Power and Foreign Policy Performance: Comparison of China and Iran. Foreign Relations Quarterly. 3(1).49-74. [In Persian]  
  57. Saree-ul-Qalam, M (2020). Are we isolated?. The official website of Saree-ul-Qalam, M. June 6. Available at: https://sariolghalam.com/2020/05/26/ .  [In Persian]
  58. Saree-ul-Qalam, M (2022a). Western strategy towards Iran. The website of Sareli-ul-Qalam, M. Available at: https://sariolghalam.com/2023/02/17 /%d 8%a7%d8.  [In Persian]
  59. Saree-ul-Qalam, M (2022b). Iran and the new geopolitics of the world. Andisheh Poya monthly magazine in online news. In: https://www.khabaronline.ir/news/1614005. [In Persian]              
  60. Sheikhzadeh, H. (2006). Elite and Development of Iran. Tehran: Center for the Recognition of Islam and Iran. [In Persian]   
  61. Sifzadeh, S.H (2006). Principles of International Relations. Tehran: Samt Publication.  [In Persian]
  62. Sneberg, C (2015). The purpose of American strategic Culture. Oslo: University of Oslo Press.
  63. Turku, H (2009). Isolationist States in an Interdependent World. Publisher: Rutledge.
  64. Urbatsch, R (2010). Isolationism and Domestic Politics. Journal of Conflict Resolution. 54(3). 471 –492.
  65. Zarei , B; Piltan, F (2018). The Role of Geopolitical Factors in the Emergence of Iranian Realism. Human Geography Research Quarterly. 50(2).491-508.  [In Persian]  
Volume 21, Issue 1
Spring 2025
Pages 36-68

  • Receive Date 15 May 2024
  • Revise Date 05 June 2024
  • Accept Date 14 June 2024